May 2, 2024
With the 2024 NFL Draft behind us, we can check the results of how the prominent mock drafts fared.
I was very happy with the results of my 2023 NFL Mock Draft, but not so much this past year. I hit some selections outside of the top 10, but the early part of my mock was destroyed because I got duped into thinking there would be a trade that never occurred. Conversely, Charlie Campbell had the most accurate 2024 NFL Mock Draft with 13 correct picks. This is hardly a surprise, given his amazing track record.
Here is how all of the prominent 2024 NFL Mock Drafts scored (if I’m missing someone’s mock, please e-mail me.) Keep in mind that we are scoring prospects to correct teams:
Charlie Campbell – 13
Peter Schrager – 11
Ben Wasley – 11
Jacob Camenker – 10
Albert Breer – 9
Bucky Brooks – 9
Jason La Canfora – 9
Charles Davis – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Matt Miller – 8
Trevor Sikemma – 8
Lance Zierlein – 8
Dane Brugler – 7
Walter Cherepinsky – 7
Eric Edholm – 7
Tony Pauline – 7
Ryan Wilson – 7
Matt Youmans – 7
Shane Hallam – 6
Jimmy Kempski – 6
Thor Nystrom – 6
Pete Prisco – 6
Chad Reuter – 6
Evan Silva – 6
R.J. White – 6
Cris Collinsworth – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Chris Trapasso – 5
Will Brinson – 4
Mike Florio – 4
Rob Rang – 3
Peter King – Retired
Mel Kiper – Did not do a mock draft this year (WTF?)
Jon Ledyard – Unable to find his mock draft
Todd McShay – No longer with ESPn
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2023:
Walter Cherepinsky – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Jacob Camenker – 7
Charlie Campbell – 7
Lance Zierlein – 7
Shane Hallam – 6
Todd McShay – 6
Trevor Sikemma – 6
Dane Brugler – 5
Cris Collinsworth – 5
Charles Davis – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Pete Prisco – 5
R.J. White – 5
Ryan Wilson – 5
Kyle Crabbs – 4
Jason La Canfora – 4
Jimmy Kempski – 4
Tony Pauline – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Albert Breer – 3
Will Brinson – 3
Mike Florio – 3
Joe Marino – 3
Matt Miller – 3
Thor Nystrom – 3
Peter Schrager – 3
Evan Silva – 3
Chris Trapasso – 3
Matt Youmans – 3
Eric Edholm – 2
Peter King – 2
Mel Kiper – 2
Chad Reuter – 2
Bucky Brooks – 1
Jon Ledyard – Unable to find his mock draft
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2022:
Charlie Campbell – 11
Eric Edholm – 10
Dane Brugler – 9
Matt Youmans – 9
Albert Breer – 8
Walter Cherepinsky – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Thor Nystrom – 8
R.J. White – 8
Jacob Camenker – 7
Jimmy Kempski – 7
Mel Kiper – 7
Kyle Crabbe – 6
Charles Davis – 6
Shane Hallam – 6
Peter King – 6
Jason La Canfora – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Peter Schrager – 6
Chris Trapasso – 6
Ryan Wilson – 6
Lance Zierlein – 6
Jon Ledyard – 5
Todd McShay – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Evan Silva – 5
Will Brinson – 4
Bucky Brooks – 4
Cris Collinsworth – 4
Mike Florio – 4
Pete Prisco – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Trevor Sikemma – 4
Joe Marino – 3
Chad Reuter – 3
Matt Miller – 1
Scott Wright – Retired from mock drafting
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2021:
Josh Norris – 15
Charlie Campbell – 13 (not including Etienne to JAX at 33)
Dane Brugler – 13
Trevor Sikemma – 12
Ryan Wilson – 12
Jacob Camenker – 11
Walter Cherepinsky – 11
Charles Davis – 11
Evan Silva – 11
Todd McShay – 10
Chris Trapasso – 10
R.J. White – 10
Albert Breer – 9
Kyle Crabbe – 9
Lance Zierlein – 9
Peter King – 8
Jon Ledyard – 8
Will Brinson – 7
Mel Kiper – 7
Jason La Canfora – 7
Joe Marino – 7
Pete Prisco – 7
Daniel Jeremiah – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Bucky Brooks – 5
Charley Casserly – 5
Thor Nystrom – 5
Rob Rang – 5
Chad Reuter – 5
Pete Schrager – 5
Cris Collinsworth – 4
Mike Florio – 4
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2020:
Jacob Camenker – 11
Peter King – 10
Scott Wright – 10
Charley Casserly – 9
Pete Schrager – 9
Walter Cherepinsky – 8
Kyle Crabbe – 8
Charles Davis – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Matt Miller – 8
Thor Nystrom – 8
Charlie Campbell – 7
Mike Florio – 7
Jon Ledyard – 7
Joe Marino – 7
Todd McShay – 7
Josh Norris – 7
Tony Pauline – 7
Chad Reuter – 7
Trevor Sikemma – 7
Chris Trapasso – 7
Will Brinson – 6
Dane Brugler – 6
Cris Collinsworth – 6
Mel Kiper – 6
Lance Zierlein – 6
Rob Rang – 5
R.J. White – 5
Bucky Brooks – 4
Evan Silva – 4
Ryan Wilson – 4
Pete Prisco – 3
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2019:
Charlie Campbell – 12
Walter Cherepinsky – 9
Todd McShay – 9
Pete Schrager – 9
Trevor Sikemma -9
Dane Brugler – 8
Jacob Camenker – 8
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Evan Silva – 8
Bucky Brooks – 7
Kyle Crabbe – 7
Peter King – 7
Mel Kiper – 7
Matt Miller – 7
Josh Norris – 7
Lance Zierlein – 7
Charles Davis – 6
Mike Florio – 6
Ryan Wilson – 6
Scott Wright – 6
Will Brinson – 5
Charley Casserly – 5
Joe Marino – 5
Bob McGinn – 5
Chris Trapasso – 5
R.J. White – 5
Thor Nystrom – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Jon Ledyard – 3
Tony Pauline – 3
Chad Reuter – 3
Pete Prisco – 2
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2018:
Walter Cherepinsky – 10
Evan Silva – 10
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Rob Rang – 8
Mike Mayock – 7
Todd McShay – 6
Tony Pauline – 6
Bob McGinn – 5
Josh Norris – 5
Pete Prisco – 5
Pete Schrager – 5
Lance Zierlein – 5
Charlie Campbell – 4
Mel Kiper – 4
Will Brinson – 3
Jacob Camenker – 3
Charley Casserly – 3
Scott Wright – 3
Bucky Brooks – 2
Dane Brugler – 2
Peter King – 2
Matt Miller – 2
Thor Nystrom – 2
Chris Trapasso – 2
R.J. White – 2
Chad Reuter – 1
Here’s how the mock drafters fared in 2017:
Charlie Campbell – 9
Daniel Jeremiah – 8
Peter King – 7
Lance Zierlein – 6
Matt Miller – 6
Walter Cherepinsky – 5
Mike Mayock – 5
Evan Silva – 5
Scott Wright – 5
Bucky Brooks – 4
Todd McShay – 4
Josh Norris – 4
Tony Pauline – 4
Pete Prisco – 4
Rob Rang – 4
Pete Schrager – 4
Dane Brugler – 3
Chad Reuter – 3
Charley Casserly – 2
Mel Kiper – 2
Bob McGinn – 2
Let’s combine the past eight years and see who has the most correct over that span:
Charlie Campbell – 76
Walter Cherepinsky – 66
Daniel Jeremiah – 62
Jacob Camenker – 57
Lance Zierlein – 54
Dane Brugler – 53
Josh Norris – 53
Peter Schrager – 52
Evan Silva – 52
Trevor Sikemma – 46
Charles Davis – 44
Tony Pauline – 43
Peter King – 42
R.J. White – 41
Ryan Wilson – 40
Rob Rang – 37
Todd McShay – 37
Bucky Brooks – 36
Thor Nystrom – 36
Pete Prisco – 36
Chris Trapasso – 36
Mel Kiper – 35
Matt Miller – 35
Kyle Crabbs – 34
Will Brinson – 32
Chad Reuter – 30
Albert Breer – 29
Mike Florio – 27
Jason La Canfora – 26
Joe Marino – 25
Cris Collinsworth – 24
Jon Ledyard – 23
Ben Wasley – 11
For a full list of mocks, check out our NFL Mock Draft Database.
2024 NFL Mock Draft - April 23
NFL Power Rankings - Feb. 22
Fantasy Football Rankings - Feb. 19
NFL Picks - Feb. 12
